Should I Chase The Rally – Greenspan Was Wrong Then Right On Animal Spirits

Photo courtesy of Ms Jeannie Tan, S.F.


People are calling and chatrooms are buzzing with friends saying they were cashing out of their DBS stocks at SGD 18, after the steepest rally since 2009, which I would not attribute to boasting, on account of the nature of our friendship, although I cannot say the same for the rest who had to post their regret when DBS hit SGD 18.40 before closing the week at SGD 17.83. Others are celebrating renewing their rents at 10% discounts and it is certainly looking like a festive period for most investors so far, who are clearly ignoring the capital losses in their bond portfolios because it is only right to treat those bonds, as their category implies, as fixed income, to be held to maturity.

Should I Chase The Rally - Greenspan Was Wrong Then Right On Animal Spirits

Graph : Steepest and  Sharpest rally in DBS stock since 2009


It is also just too bad for celebrations if their favourite char kway teow seller passes off because char kway teow is unhealthy business, not just for the consumers, but the cooks as well, having to deal with the endless hours of grease, smoke and soot that will undoubtedly take a carcinogenic toll on their lives and who would want to sell char kway teow in the future when insurance companies start deeming it a hazardous profession ?

Should I Chase The Rally - Greenspan Was Wrong Then Right On Animal Spirits 1
Carrot cake at Commonwealth Crescent


As I devour my plate of fried carrot cake, I wonder about the rare stock rally we are witnessing and if I should chase it because I have been insufficiently invested, according to the standards of Greed, as many of us would be and I have about a dozen new emails in the past week on how the Dow would sustain towards 20,000 for a mother of all rallies that is here to stay ! and to persist for a long time more. Who would not expect it especially when we had the Dow set 5 consecutive new historical highs every single day of this memorable December week, breaking 5 milestones in a month.
Should I Chase The Rally - Greenspan Was Wrong Then Right On Animal Spirits 2Source :


Did I just really miss out on the biggest bull run of my life ? Or did I miss something in the past 4 weeks since the US just elected a president with the lowest favourability rating in modern history ?  Who had managed to unleash “animal spirits”, on the 20th anniversary of Alan Greenspan’s “Irrational Exuberance” speech on 5th Dec, 1996. For the record, the Dow continued to make new highs 3 years following Greenspan’s comments.

Well, analysts are probably doubling up as fantasy and sci-fiction writers right now – dreaming of their Trump future and writing to justify their jobs because having no clue is not in the job scope. Therefore, we are just 1 month into the new Trump fairytale reality and the CNN Fear and Greed Index is still not close to 100 yet.


Should I Chase The Rally - Greenspan Was Wrong Then Right On Animal Spirits 3Source :


Perhaps its about the tax repatriation holiday that Donald Trump has promised ? Analysts are expecting more stock buy-backs than jobs created or investments which is all speculative, of course, but good enough reason to buy shares. Alternatively, no reports have mentioned the possibility of buying bonds back at a big discount at the rate the markets are selling off.

Nonetheless let’s do a quick tally of the month and the price action ranked.

Should I Chase The Rally - Greenspan Was Wrong Then Right On Animal Spirits 4


Darn, it looks like we should have thrown it all into DBS and quickly sold it at $18 like my friends did right before the news of their HK branch scandal broke ! Because the gains would have beat buying the USD and the Dow combined and it is not even as if they have announced a stock buyback programme.

Is It Trump Or Is It Oil  Or Is It Just Sentiments ?

Economic growth uncertainty has risen since the US elections with the sustained strength of the US dollar that will threaten the emerging markets reliant on USD funding. Global trade is threatened by the election promise to keep jobs in the US and more recently, to impose a 35% tax on companies that move their productions overseas and try to sell their products to Americans.

It got even better last Thursday with an apparent tough stance on China.

“China is responsible for almost half of America’s trade deficit,” Trump said at a rally Thursday evening Des Moines, Iowa. “China is not a market economy … they haven’t played by the rules, and they know it’s time that they’re going to start. They’re going to start. They’re going to.”

Notwithstanding the good news  is that economic data from the developed markets have not looked stronger this whole year with PMI numbers and economic surprise indices all mostly beating expectations and inflation gauges turn to healthy as oil prices look set to heard higher especially with this weekend’s renewed production cut pledges, something that has not happened since 2001.

We may even want to thank Saudi Arabia over Trump for this month’s windfall because it is official now – higher oil prices are actually good for the economy as it spurs inflation and prices will rise, including asset prices such as stocks although we are not sure about Gold and real estate ?

It is far easier to speculate in the pot of gold at the end of the Dow Transport Index which is up nearly 10% for the month, head and shoulders over the rest, for the promises that Trump has made, as Ken Rogoff suggests in Trump Boom ?, that the confidence will be boosted in an economy that is already growing at 3%, if the new administration gets it right although it can still end very badly, which is something we should not worry about at the moment.

What If We Cannot See The Reasons to Cheer ?

Here in Singapore, most of the stressed out Singaporeans that we wrote about last week, could be struggling to find a reason to cheer or even be upbeat with the 5% return the STI has made in the past month as the SGD currency weakened 3.2% against the USD.  Except for those who put all their money into DBS, OCBC, UOB, Genting, Sembcorp, Keppel Corp and gang, which have outperformed the STI.

The Japanese have, on the other hand, been rejoicing with their currency weakness (-8.8% on the month)that is only bested by the Mexican Peso which has lost 10% against the greenback, giving the Nikkei stock index a massive 9.3% boost. That has managed to pull Japanese retail sales up to -0.1% YoY, less negative than before, while China slows to a 10Y low of 10% even as the US and EU give promising single digit growth.


Should I Chase The Rally - Greenspan Was Wrong Then Right On Animal Spirits 5


To continue reading….